Twenty Minutes Into the Worst Gig of My Life, I Realized the Setlist Was the Problem
Photo: PattayaPatrol, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
There's a particular kind of silence that happens when you're four songs into a set and the room has already checked out. Not hostile silence — that you can work with. I mean the polite kind. The kind where people are nodding along to their own conversations and you've become a nice piece of furniture.
I hit that wall twenty minutes into a Tuesday night gig at a small listening room outside Kansas City. Eleven people in the audience. One of them was my cousin. And I want to be clear: this wasn't a bad gig because of the crowd. It was a bad gig because of me. Specifically, because of a piece of paper I'd been carrying around for two years without ever really questioning it.
The Setlist I'd Been Protecting
Here's what I played that night, in order:
- "Highway 9" — the mid-tempo crowd favorite
- "Borrowed Time" — the single
- "Something About Rain" — the ballad
- "Ghost of a Good Year" — another mid-tempo track
- "Firelight" — the singalong
Looks reasonable on paper, right? Upbeat opener, hit single early, ballad for texture, back to energy, big finish. That ordering had been my default since roughly forever. It was built on advice I got at a songwriter workshop years ago: "Open with your strongest up-tempo number and never lose momentum."
The problem is that "never lose momentum" turned into "never breathe." Songs two, four, and five were all in the same tempo pocket. Song three, the ballad, felt like a speed bump instead of a moment. And my stage banter — the little connective tissue between songs — had calcified into the same three jokes I'd been telling since 2019. I was running a jukebox, not a show.
By the time I got to "Firelight," the room had thinned to seven people, and I remember thinking, mid-chorus, that I would pay real money to be anywhere else.
The Drive Home That Fixed Everything
Here's the thing about a truly flat gig: it stings for about an hour, and then it becomes the most useful information you've ever received. Somewhere around Columbia, Missouri, I pulled over at a gas station, bought a gas station coffee, and started talking out loud to myself like a person who should not be left unsupervised.
The core realization was embarrassingly simple. I had been sequencing my sets like a playlist — optimized, consistent, interchangeable. But a good show isn't a playlist. It's a conversation. It has tension and release. It has a low point. It earns its big moments by going small first.
The Rewrite
Here's the setlist I played two weeks later at the next gig:
- "Something About Rain" — yes, the ballad, cold open
- "Highway 9"
- A brand-new unrecorded song, played solo, no intro
- "Firelight"
- "Borrowed Time" — reworked, slower, stripped down
- "Ghost of a Good Year" — full-band finale
Opening with the ballad felt like walking a tightrope with no net. "Something About Rain" is quiet, patient, and honestly a little sad — everything the workshop advice told me never to lead with. But here's what happened: because there was nothing before it, people actually heard it. No expectations, no warm-up, no competition. The room leaned in because there was nothing to lean away from.
Then "Highway 9" landed like a gift instead of a formality. The untested new song in the three slot became a moment of vulnerability — "nobody's heard this, and I'm a little nervous about it" — which, it turns out, is a sentence audiences respond to more than any joke I've ever told. And saving "Ghost of a Good Year" for last gave the show an actual destination.
Why the 'Boring' Song Became the Centerpiece
"Something About Rain" had been languishing in the middle of my sets for years. I'd written it off as the ballad. The filler. The song you play so the fast songs hit harder afterward.
Turns out it was never a boring song. It was a badly placed one. In the opening slot, it became the emotional anchor of the entire night — the moment that told the audience what kind of show this was going to be and whether I trusted them enough to start quiet. I've opened with it at nearly every gig since, and it gets more genuine comments than anything else I play.
The lesson I keep relearning in this business: when something isn't working, check whether it's broken or just in the wrong seat. That disastrous Tuesday cost me nothing but my pride, and it rewrote my live show from the ground up. Worst gig of my life. Best trade I ever made.